These maxims are unstated assumptions we have in conversations. Presupposition and entailment21 free download as powerpoint presentation. Entailment, presupposition, and implicature entailment a entails b if, when a is true, b must. The introduction of accommodation in conditionals and factives and the neo. The idea was developed independently, but in rather di. Presupposition and entailment slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. A presupposition is something that you assume to be true, especially something which you. It is selfcontradictory to conjoin s with the denial of sa if sa is a necessary condition of the truth, simply, of s. Presupposition and entailment presupposition and entailment stiver, james l. The numerical syllogism and existential presupposition murphree, wallace a. Presuppositions are projected based on the properties of their syntactic and semantic en vironment. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here. Presupposition refers to a basic premise that is assumed to be true before entailment takes place. There is another kind of inference, called a presupposition, that is not an entailment but also cannot be classified as abductive or inductive.
For instance, finding after the forgoing search is connected with the presupposition that the search took place. It can be concluded that the difficulty of distinguishing pair of entailment. Exercise presupposition or entailment lexical resource. Similarly, entailment is logical or truthful consequence it is something that necessarily follows from what is asserted. Pdf understanding presupposition and entailment balaji. Strawson provides technical development of his partial logical approach to presupposition in strawson 1952. Much more central to pragmatics in the past than now. Presupposition and entailment yuanli fan atlantis press. Morgan, jerry, 1969, on the treatment of presupposition in transformational grammar, in papers from the fifth regional meeting, chicago linguistic society, university of chicago, 16777. Entailmentpresuppositionimplicature comparisions flashcards. Temporal clauses subordinate clauses introduced by temporal conjunctions before he died, frege hadhadnt written about presuppositions. Ginsberg, mitchell, notre dame journal of formal logic, 1972. A presupposition of a part of an utterance is sometimes also a presupposition of the whole utterance, and sometimes not. Only, presupposition and implicature the meaning of the english adverb only has been the subject of intense debate.
Presupposition download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Intuitively, a presupposition constitutes a necessary assumption required to understand the meaning of a sentence. Presupposition and entailment, the southern journal of. Entailment and presupposition by zainurrahman entailment definition. Pdf distinguishing entailment and presupposition under. Types of presuppostions make your conversational contribution such as is required, at the stage at which it occurs, by the accepted purpose or direction of the talk exchange in which you are engaged.
Entailment differs from implicature in that for the latter the truth of a suggests the truth of b, but does not require it. Presuppositions, entailment and implicatures by flavia. More specifically, this study attempts to reveal the relation between entailment and presupposition. Thus, this research aims to analyze and test pairs of entailment and pairs of presupposition by using negation in utterances.
Entailment also differs from presupposition in that in presupposition, the truth of what one is presupposing is taken for granted. Presupposition and entailment james pustejovsky september 23, 2005 2 truth and falsity. Presupposition and entailment21 logical consequence. Rc hums 392 english grammar and meaning triggers for. Some of these are 1 presupposition and entailment seem to be. Speakers have presuppositions while sentences, not speakers, have entailments. Presupposition and entailment by veronica marin on prezi. Thus finding in this sense means that the activity of seeking came to a successful end, which is the case that we dealt with in paragraph 3. Richard nordquist is professor emeritus of rhetoric and english at georgia southern university and the author of several universitylevel grammar and composition textbooks. It has been argued that the latter is a presupposition, a conversational implicature, and an entailment. This process of an addressee assuming that a presupposition is true even in the absence of explicit information that it is, is called presupposition accommodation. This sentence presupposes that there is a king of france, which there is currently not. Entailment is a relation between sentence meanings, or propositions.
Presupposition, broadly conceived, is a type of inference associated with utterances of naturallanguage sentences. Entailment and presupposition university of babylon. The reason for the widespread belief to the contrary, he. Entailment and presupposition shows the different relationship between sentences. Presupposed content and entailments in natural language. Presupposition definition of presupposition by the free.
Decide whether in the following examples the second sentence is a presupposition or an entailment of the first one. This work presents a procedural account of the socalled projection problem for presupposition. Sometimes, speaking loosely, we talk as though it were a relation between sentences. Bill was looking for the receipt for some period of time. The performance of both of the groups of students that have undertaken the first test is close. The relation between sand sa in the first case is that sentails sa. In pragmatics presupposition is what the speaker assumes to be the case prior to making an utterance. Difference between entailment and presupposition compare. Presuppositional inferences are distinguished from other kinds of inferences, especially from atissue inferences a. Presuppositions if entailments are crucial semantic relation, presuppositions, it may be said, are typical pragmatic relation. A truth based approach to entailment entailment a the evil overlord assassinated the man in the red shirt.
In semantics and pragmatics, entailment is the principle that under certain conditions the truth of one statement ensures the truth of a second statement. Both of them are the meaning and information deduced from the sentence itself. The presupposition of 5a is that right before january 1, john smoked. A note on strawson entailment illustrate the second argument projection problem and the example in6 illustrates the ptoqproblem. As always, we should distinguish between a presupposition and a mere entailment. A sentence s presupposes p if p must be true in order for s to have a truth value conversational. The entailment relation here results from a syntactic source. Entailment, which is not a pragmatic concept, is what logically follows from what is asserted in the utterance. While bill was looking for the receipt, mary continued work on the form. A presupposition is background belief, relating to an utterance, that must be mutually known or assumed by the speaker and addressee for the utterance to be considered appropriate in context generally will remain a necessary assumption whether the utterance is. Presupposition definition and meaning collins english. For instance, the phrase my wife triggers the presupposition that i have a wife. Banjar presupposition seems to contrast with entailment.
True if the actual world is in the pat is hungry half. One thing that is clear is that, like entailments, presuppositions are tied to the conventional meaning of words and phrases. Click download or read online button to get presupposition book now. Entailments when we utter declarative sentences, many things get communicated. Presupposition can also be seen as a relation between propositions, although many linguists including george yule prefer to see presupposition as strictly pragmatic, and a relation between. Presupposition triggers another characteristic feature of presuppositions is that they are tied to the presence of certain words or syntactic configurations, socalled presupposition triggers. Implicature arising from observing or flouting gricean maxims. The study deals with the notion of entailment, its types, i. The linguistic framework general conditions on a semantic theory the relation between syntax and semantics on the nature of semantic features and the semantic component on the form of semantic features on the nature of. Presupposition is when the speaker assumes some background information when making a statement. The main message and the entailments of the main message. If x presupposes y, the negative counterpart of x also presupposes y. Strawsonian notion of presupposition is dependent on the notion of logical entailment.
In cases of symmetric entailment, the antecedent or. Source for information on entailment, presupposition, and implicature. For example, the question of whether i will turn 28 this year first of all presupposes that i am real. The achievement of the experimental group that had been given lessons in this topic is anticipated to be better than that of the control group in the second try. Presupposition and implicature 3 2 presupposition the presuppositions of an utterance are the pieces of information that the speaker assumes or acts as if she assumes in order for her utterance to be meaningful in the current context.
It is assumed that presuppositions embedded in complex sentences are subject to no projection rules or adhoc conditions whatever, but are in fact satisfied in appropriate contexts in a completely uniform way. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Presupposition the handbook of pragmatics wiley online. Presupposition notes stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Bergmann, merrie, notre dame journal of formal logic, 1982. Further early discussion of strawsons proposals is found in sellars 1954, strawson 1954, and nerlich 1967. Today we discuss lexical and syntactic ambiguity, entailment, paraphrasing and contradictions. Ali wannas lafi university of basrah college of arts introduction it is common knowledge for us that in any kind of verbal interaction speakers convey most of the communicational content by way of implication rather than by making overt statements. The present paper attempts to explain what the logicians or philosophers have said regarding presupposition and entailment in the domain of semantics and pragmatics. Veronica marin bedoya presupposition and entailment maria jose hernandez paola prada entailement depend on sentence meaning not the context in which the sentence is used. In pragmatics, entailment falls in a category with implicature and presupposition. Nov 09, 2016 key difference entailment vs presupposition when we hear an utterance, we usually try to understand not only what the words mean, but what the speaker of those words intends to convey. What is a presupposition sil glossary of linguistic terms. This knowledge allows us to communicate much more than we actually say.
Something the speaker assumes to be the case before making an utterance speaker oriented entailment. Presupposition definitiontypes of presupposition some commonpresupposition triggers 3. True under some possible circumstances, false under others. Lexical alternatives as a source of pragmatic presuppositions. Originally presented as the authors thesis, london, 1973 includes bibliographical references pages 222230 and index introduction. Apr 17, 2012 pragmatics presupposition and entailnment 1.
Presupposition and implicature 5 dominant one, though, at present, it probably manifests itself largely as noncommitment about the full picture even as more and more of the heavylifting is assigned to the pragmatics abbott, 2006. Entailment is related to the concepts of presupposition and implicature. Towards a common logical semantics for presupposition and entailment, journal of semantics, 9. The classic and often mentioned example of this is, the king of france is not ill. Entailment and presupposition are two pragmatic elements that help us in this. He believes that the gap between the meanings of the connectives and operators of standard logic are much closer to the meanings of their natural language counterparts than had been assumed. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. We make use of the theory of logical consequence operation as a general framework to show that it is impossible to find a logical consequence operation which mirrors the philosophical intuitions of the strawsons notions of presupposition. In 2, for instance, the presupposition in 2g is tied to the presence of againthe word again is the trigger for the presupposition in 2g. All three deal with assumptions made by the listener or reader about a situation. Entailment, presupposition, and implicature entailment, as used by philosophers, is a term of art that, unlike logical consequence, lacks a precise definition that is consistently adhered to by those who employ it.
Presupposition and entailment in pragmatics halaman all. Entailment also happens when one set of objects is included in anothers. Presupposition and implicature stanford university. The alleged ambiguity of negation and the contrasts among presupposition, assertion, and direct entailment. This broad characterization encompasses everything from general conversational norms to the particulars of. In other words either we have a new relation of entailment or if we prefer the classical notion of entailment then we have in presupposition a new primitive nondefined logical concept.
1391 1093 51 1189 35 1154 53 360 216 435 744 1047 216 429 1123 606 789 40 1572 837 777 211 73 714 272 584 1208 206 1191 308 418 867 908 1208 692